17 Holly Hill Lane

New Vernon, New Jersey $3,499,000

When a stunning exterior, immaculate interior, majestic setting, and prime location top your list, look no further than this custom Colonial. Built-in 2001 and renovated in 2013 and 2018, this impressive home rests on a wooded, park-like setting close to historic Silver Lake. Situated at the top of a quiet cul-de-sac, this engaging home is positioned to take full advantage of all this desirable, upscale community has to offer. Curb appeal is only the beginning.

Framed by classic columns, a covered front entry leads you into an elegant foyer. The formal living and dining rooms lie to either side, with the rest of the main living area beyond. The living room, dining room, kitchen, and great room all include cozy wood-burning fireplaces to keep you and your loved ones warm throughout the year.

The spacious eat-in kitchen includes a chef’s array of premium appliances, making it as easy as can be to prepare fabulous meals when entertaining. Past French doors leading out to the backyard is an expansive great room, offering plenty of space to relax or entertain. A sumptuous, cherry wood-paneled library rounds out the first floor.

Five bedrooms, including the generous master suite, are comfortably nestled on the second floor. In addition to a large dressing room and luxurious en suite bathroom, the master also includes an attached room that could be an office, sitting area, or nursery. Both this room and the bedroom have private balconies with stunning vistas.

The finished basement adds an additional full bathroom, bedroom, recreation room, media room, and more flexible leisure space to the home. The attic is prepared for finishing, with electricity, HVAC, and plumbing already installed, giving you the chance to easily add finished space and customize it however you like.


  • Beautifully finished across 3 levels with a classic main living area, comfortable bedrooms, and exceptional leisure space
  • Premier location in a highly desirable area
  • Top of a cul-de-sac with a park-like setting
  •  Partially finished, walk-up attic with electricity, HVAC, plumbing, and the potential for finishing
  • Interior features include French doors, coffered ceilings, tray ceilings, vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, marble tiles, recessed lights, and custom built-ins
  • Wood-burning fireplaces in the living room, great room, dining room, kitchen, master bedroom, and additional bedroom
  • Eat-in kitchen with custom cabinets, under-cabinet lighting, tile backsplash, granite counters, premium appliances, wine fridge, center island, 2 pantries (1 walk-in), and separate breakfast area
  • Master bedroom with private balcony, dressing room, en suite bath with jetted tub and bidet, and office/sitting room with additional private balcony
  • Library, mudroom, and powder room on the first floor; Laundry room and sitting room on the second floor; Recreation room, media room, additional laundry room, flex space, and full bathroom in the finished basement
  • 4-zone central air conditioning and radiant heating
  • Security system
  • Home Audio system
  • Intercom system
  • Thermal windows
  • House generator


  • Hand-split cedar shake roof
  • Partial stone and wood exterior with cedar composition siding
  • Attached 3-car garage
  • Paved driveway with additional parking
  • Patio, courtyard, large heated pool, and spa, underground lawn sprinklers
  • Fenced backyard
  • Wooded lot in a park-like setting
  • Close to NYC transportation and historic Silver Lake
  • Easy access to major highways, business centers, and airports


  • Custom Colonial
  • 5 bedrooms, 6 full bathrooms, 1 half bathroom
  • Built: 2001 / Renovated: 2013 and 2018

Virtual Tour

gross internal area

17 Holly Hill Lane

New Vernon, New Jersey

Michelle Pais
Michelle Pais
CEO | Broker Associate Signature Realty NJ | Michelle Pais Group
One of NJ’s Top Realtors